 |
17 Jun 2002
Adaptive optics are seen as an expensive luxury that only professional astronomers can afford. However, as Michael Hatcher reports, one European project is intent on bringing their capabilities to many other applications.
From Opto & Laser Europe May 2001
Adaptive optics is something of an expensive luxury. So far, astronomers have been the main beneficiaries of the technique and there has been little penetration of other niche areas or mass markets. However, whereas the cost of a large astronomical system typically runs into many millions of dollars, the biggest block to the application of adaptive optics in more mainstream areas has been the lack of small, high-quality, inexpensive adaptive elements.
Finding a low-cost solution in adaptive optics has been the main thrust of an EU project that ends this month. Micro-optical silicon systems (MOSIS) was charged with making affordable adaptive optics in the shape of deformable mirrors and with finding novel applications and potential markets for them.
Gleb Vdovin is at the hub of the MOSIS project. He and his team at Delft University of Technology in the Netherlands have successfully developed low-cost micromachined membrane deformable mirrors, MMDMs, while other project partners have looked to develop a range of applications for the devices. Vdovin set up Okotech, a company based in Delft, to make and sell the MMDMs. Okotech has since mutated into Flexible Optical, which is looking to move its attention towards more commercial applications as well as addressing the scientific market.
Applications investigated under MOSIS include beam shaping to improve the beam quality of
high-power lasers, ultrashort pulse compression, retinal imaging and vision correction.
At the University of Applied Science in Münster, Germany, Ulrich Wittrock has been using an MMDM
in a master-oscillator power amplifier system. "We wanted to correct small fluctuations in thermal lensing and
higher-order thermo-optical aberrations [that degrade beam quality]," said Wittrock.
The MMDM both analyses and corrects these aberrations caused by the amplifier rods. The result
should be a multitude of benefits for industrial laser users. Wittrock explained: "The better beam quality
enables the use of smaller, lighter and cheaper focusing optics and smaller diameter fibres. This, in turn, gives
higher cutting speeds, a larger stand-off distance between the focusing optics and the workpiece, and a larger
depth of focus."
Despite these figures, Wittrock believes that commercial interest in such industrial high-power
applications is still several years in the future. He said: "In my opinion, the more immediate applications of
MMDMs will be diode laser beam shaping and temporal pulse shaping in ultrafast lasers. There are also many
imaging applications where low-cost MMDMs can significantly improve optical performance."
One such application is in retinal scanning. Vdovin says that, because the size of the MMDMs is similar
to that of the human eye, they are ideal for this use - being of a similar size means that the aberrations are also
of a similar magnitude.
At the Universidad de Murcia in Spain, Pablo Artal, a pioneer in adaptive optics and particularly its use in
human vision, is using the MMDMs to develop so-called "super-vision" systems to improve human visual
performance beyond the natural limit. Having demonstrated this with a 1 m2 breadboard set-up, he
is now adapting the system to make a pair of spectacles - this being exactly the type of application where the
small size and weight of Vdovin's devices are so convenient.
Artal's closed-loop set-up could also correct vision in patients with unusual corneal pathologies that
cannot be corrected with conventional optics, as a visual simulator to test the effects of ophthalmic devices or
refractive surgery, and for the early detection of retinal diseases.
Artal believes that the low cost of the MMDMs means that practically any lab can afford to buy them,
and he says that they are easy to control with simple electronics and a fast response. He says that the MMDMs
proved more successful than previous efforts with spatial light modulators.
Another MOSIS partner, René Dändliker of the Institute of Microtechnology at IMT Neuchâtel in
Switzerland, has led the development of an optical fibre switch based on an MMDM. Light from a single input
fibre is redirected down one of an array of output fibres using a lens and the MMDM.
Moving the lens switches the optical output to a different fibre and the MMDM
corrects any aberrations that moving the lens induces. For example, the switch could be used as a router in
metropolitan networks. According to Frédéric Gonté and Yves-Alain Peter of IMT, who have developed and
built the prototype, the MMDM has enabled them to surpass their initial goals. "The mirror allowed us to
demonstrate a fibre switch even more massive than expected," said Gonté.
In the prototype device, the fibre pitch is 25 µm and a 37-electrode array MMDM is used. Gonté
compared a standard, flat mirror with the MMDM. He found that the MMDM increased the efficiency of the
coupling from 50% to 73% (the maximum theoretical efficiency is only 80%.
Gonté adds that a similar system with a two-dimensional hexagonal fibre bundle with a 13 µm pitch
could be extended in two dimensions to build a switch containing more than 1,000 addressable fibres. Industry
seems to like the idea. "We have several industrial interests for the fibre switch and for dynamic coupling of
doped fibre," said Gonté.
MOSIS has made these applications possible at an affordable price - the basic cost of a 10 mm aperture
MMDM is USD 1,000. Frustratingly for Vdovin, the low price of MMDMs compared with conventional
adaptive optics systems puts some customers off, because they see the low price as a reflection of low quality.
The most popular MMDM is a 15 mm, 37-channel device that costs USD 60 per channel. Vdovin says that the
generally accepted figure is USD 1,000 per channel.
Flexible Optical currently has no direct competition and Vdovin is seeing a steady rather than a
spectacular rise in orders. "We've sold over 50 systems and more than 150 MMDMs," he told OLE.
A more dramatic increase in sales demands a mainstream application and could come from astronomy -
again. The MMDM's size makes it suitable for the adaptive correction of images seen through relatively small
telescopes. Although Vdovin points out that collecting a sufficient amount of light through a relatively narrow
aperture could be a problem, bringing adaptive optics to back-garden stargazers, as well as multimillion dollar
observatories, could prove to be the mainstream breakthrough for MMDMs.
 |  |  |  |  |  |  |
| © 2024 SPIE Europe |
|
